If you’re planning a night out at a Mexican speakeasy, this guide is for you – especially if you love cocktails but feel unsure what to order once you’re past the margarita section. The challenge? Mexican speakeasies often feature mezcal-heavy menus, elevated classics, and unfamiliar names that can make ordering feel intimidating or hit-or-miss. That’s exactly where Más Por Favor shines, combining expertly crafted agave cocktails with a bartender-led experience that helps you land the right drink for your mood, your food, and your night.
Quick Answer
What to drink at a Mexican speakeasy depends on whether you want smoky (mezcal), bright (citrus), bitter (aperitif), or coffee-forward (Carajillo). Here are the best choices and when to order each.
Here’s the thing – a Mexican speakeasy isn’t about rushing through drinks. It’s about pacing, flavor, and atmosphere.
Order the wrong cocktail and you might end up:
The right cocktail, on the other hand, sets the tone – whether you’re easing into the evening or closing it out strong.
If you’re deciding how to end the night, our breakdown of Carajillo vs Espresso Martini explains which cocktail actually fits a Mexican speakeasy vibe – and which one belongs elsewhere.
If you’re just settling in, tequila-forward drinks are the safest (and smartest) way to start.
These drinks pair perfectly with lighter bites, street tacos, and early conversations – especially if you’re starting in a hidden speakeasy after tacos up front.
Mezcal is the soul of modern Mexican speakeasy culture. If you like complexity and depth, this is your lane.
Pro tip: If you’ve never had mezcal before, ask your bartender to guide you – quality mezcal should be smoky and smooth, not harsh.
Some Mexican cocktails are meant to drink with food, not just beside it.
These shine with bold flavors like al pastor, mole, or anything rich and spiced.
Late-night Mexican speakeasy culture has a clear winner.
It’s rich, energizing, slightly sweet, and keeps the night alive without tipping into chaos. This is why Carajillos have become a staple in top-tier Mexican cocktail bars.
Here’s a simple trick:
Ask your bartender for the house favorite or what they’re pouring most that night.
At places like Más Por Favor’s hidden tequila speakeasy, bartenders actually want to guide you – especially if you tell them whether you prefer smoky, refreshing, or spirit-forward drinks.
Behind the secret tunnel, Más Por Favor blends:
It’s not just about ordering a drink – it’s about finding your drink for the night.
That’s part of what makes Más Por Favor a truly Unique Mexican Speakeasy, where the cocktails, atmosphere, and late-night energy all work together as one experience.
The Paloma is widely considered Mexico’s most popular cocktail, even more than the margarita.
Signature cocktails or mezcal-forward classics like a Mezcal Negroni or Oaxaca Old Fashioned are top choices.
Spirit-forward drinks like Old Fashioneds, Negronis, or a Carajillo make excellent nightcaps.
The Paloma holds that title for everyday popularity across Mexico.
Choosing the right cocktail at a Mexican speakeasy isn’t about memorizing the menu – it’s about matching the drink to the moment. Start light, explore mezcal when you’re ready, and close the night with intention. And if you want a place where the vibe, the drinks, and the guidance all come together naturally, Más Por Favor delivers the full experience.
Check out our full menu or Reserve your table today!
We are located at 3879 Spring Mountain Rd Las Vegas, NV 89102
